雷哥网GMAT-【OG20-P596-722题】Newspaper editors should not allow reporters to wr_OG18新题

逻辑CR-15437 【难度:680-700】

报告题目错误

请选择错误类型：

请描述一下这个错误：

取消

建议使用官方纸质指南，查看对照完整题目

【OG20-P596-722题】

Newspaper editors should not allow reporters to write the headlines for their own stories. The reason for this is that, while the headlines that reporters themselves write are often clever, what typically makes them clever is that they allude to little-known information that is familiar to the reporter but that never appears explicitly in the story itself.

Which of the following, if true, most strengthens the argument?

A

The reporter who writes a story is usually better placed than the reporter's editor is to judge what the story’s most newsworthy features are.
分析A选项
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

B

To write a headline that is clever, a person must have sufficient understanding of the story that the headline accompanies.
分析B选项
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

C

Most reporters rarely bother to find out how other reporters have written stories and headlines about the same events that they themselves have covered.
分析C选项
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

D

For virtually any story that a reporter writes, there are at least a few people who know more about the story’s subject matter than does the reporter.
分析D选项
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

E

The kind of headlines that newspaper editors want are those that anyone who has read a reporter's story in its entirety will recognize as clever.
分析E选项
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

网友解析

暂无雷哥网文字解析

当前版本由 285452zdsb 更新于2021-05-10 11:55:45 感谢由 285452zdsb 对此题目的解答所做出的贡献。

结论是：报刊编辑不应该允许文章报告人自己写标题。

前提：因为，虽然他们自己写的标题通常会clever，因为他们会暗含一些鲜为人知的信息，报告者对这些信息很熟悉但是并没有在故事里阐明。

选项推原文加强

A. The reporter who writes a story is usually better placed than the reporter's editor is to judge what the story’s most newsworthy features are.

写故事的报告者比编辑要更好的判断清这篇故事的新闻价值点。

如果报告者更能判断清新闻价值点，那么编辑就应该允许报告者自己写题目了。与原文结论相反，削弱

B. To write a headline that is clever, a person must have sufficient understanding of the story that the headline accompanies.

为了写好一个标题，这个写标题的人必须要对故事有充分的理解。

该选项没有提供理由说明为什么编辑不应该允许文章报告者自己写标题。

C. Most reporters rarely bother to find out how other reporters have written stories and headlines about the same events that they themselves have covered.

大部分的报告者很少费力去找对于同一事件，别人怎么去写故事和标题记者不太去打探同行怎么写报道取标题。与题干论证无关

D. For virtually any story that a reporter writes, there are at least a few people who know more about the story’s subject matter than does the reporter.

对于任意一个报告者写的故事，至少有一些人比报告者更了解这个故事的内幕。从读者的角度来说，和不允许报告者给故事写题目无关。

E. The kind of headlines that newspaper editors want are those that anyone who has read a reporter's story in its entirety will recognize as clever.

编辑想要的标题是任何读了完整故事的人将会认为clever的标题。

本选项完善地建立了因果之间的联系，即，因为报告者容易是标题党，如果报告人在标题里写一些文章中都不解释的事情，读者不会认为标题是聪明clever的，所以不该让这些reporter自己写标题。增强

题目讨论（10条评论）

提交

lgw306976

题型：逻辑推理、增强解题方法：搭桥、引入他因原文的桥：提句子主干，就这三个关系，editors -----reporter -----clever A，reporter better than editors无关比较 B，a person XXX，不在桥上，可以润了 C，Most reporters 无意义概率 D ,a few people 无意义概率 E，搭起来了editors和clever的桥

0 0 回复 2023-04-20 21:14:01
willowX

题面：不能让写报告的人自己写标题，因为那会clever。正确选项却说编辑想要读者觉得clever的标题？？晕了

2 0 回复 2022-07-11 10:33:51
港三冲啊

根据标准来，如果这个标题是可以在文中出现、并被读者理解，那么就和原来的这个不让他们写标题的原因相反，那么就可以让他们写标题标准标准1！！！

0 0 回复 2021-07-05 13:36:58
835158dsivr

编辑不让作者自己写标题，因为作者经常会写一些自己很清楚，但是读者不清楚的标题。原因是作者自己去深度了解过这件事。搭桥加强：编辑希望写的标题是大家都能看懂的

1 0 回复 2020-09-15 15:32:53
746860xgow

D是削弱

0 0 回复 2020-05-27 02:48:38
243927tmbn

编辑希望不止报告的人明白所有的看过报告的人都明白

3 0 回复 2019-12-09 20:16:26
734719jvnf

最后一个that是指INFORMATION

0 0 回复 2019-10-07 20:14:54
末隐

其实这是平日里对话中常见的逻辑错误。编辑认为不应该让作者写标题。因为？？？？？。Gap: 编辑想要的的就是？？？？？父母催婚，因为结婚对我们有好处。 Gap: 我们结婚真的是父母想要的。

0 0 回复 2019-03-24 01:52:33
woody要700

E翻译，编辑想要的标题是：任何人读这个书都觉得这个标题写的聪明

0 0 回复 2019-01-11 00:17:24
Horacejin回复woody要700

great

0 0 回复 2019-04-23 19:37:09
杀鸡要用宰牛刀

矛盾在于：reporter过于了解自己写的稿子，所以会取有深度的名字，但是编辑部以及大众需要的，是仅能概括信息，而没有深度拓展的题目

6 0 回复 2018-12-10 13:55:44