中间图

Or
句子改错SC-8760 【难度:650-680】 Time Cost00:00
收藏
报告题目错误
请选择错误类型:
请描述一下这个错误:

取消

【OG20-P814-906题】

In no other historical sighting did Halley’s Comet cause such a worldwide sensation as did its return in 1910–1911.

  • 分析A选项 分析选校图标
    xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
  • 分析B选项 分析选校图标
    xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
  • 分析C选项 分析选校图标
    xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
  • 分析D选项 分析选校图标
    xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
  • 分析E选项 分析选校图标
    xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
该题平均耗时:1m23s ,平均正确率:49.8%。 该题由网友xLahAV7提供。更多GMAT题目请

网友解析

当前版本由 深海鱼 更新于2015-07-26 14:23:57 感谢由 深海鱼 对此题目的解答所做出的贡献。
翻译:历史上没有哪次哈雷彗星回归造成了跟1910-1911回归的这样的世界性范围的轰动。前后有一个大的对比,前面可说的是in no other historical sighting,as后面当然要以再什么什么这个表达方式开头才能和划线外对应,只有C了!

按钮 我有更好的解析
按钮 我有更好的解析

题目讨论 (如果对题目有任何的疑惑,欢迎在这里提出来,大家会帮你解答的哦~)
总回复图标 发表讨论

  • 用户头像

    小武

    是不是as后同主同谓要同时省略
    17楼  | 2019-04-27 17:45:53 回复
  • 用户头像

    220

    以下总结,是来源于RON的解析

    1. A physical object (comet)

    • An event (its return)

    所以comet 和 event 不平行


    E选项的in不能省略,会引起歧义

    in no other music festival did jimi hendrix cause such a spectacle as woodstock.


    this is ambiguous. there are two possible interpretations:

    (1) ...as IN woodstock (this is analogous to the intended meaning of the posted problem)比较的是音乐节和woodstock

    (2) ...as DID woodstock (i.e., you're comparing the spectacle caused by jimi hendrix to the spectacle caused by woodstock itself)比较的是jimi 和Woodstock


    the same two types of interpretations are possible for the posted problem.

    当两个选项除了只有一个小单词不同,其他都一模一样时,90%以上不能省略这个单词


    所以这题里面,若是E选项的in 变成of,CE选项的区别只有in有无省略的问题,则选有in 的C选项;


    这里such 。。as 不是举例子,而是分开用,as作为比较连词,

    such a/an X as Y  这是另外一个结构——— I have never met such a hard worker as your brother. 

    但是在这题中E选项:such a worldwide sensation as its return—是有问题的,因为语义不是这样的,所以这也是为什么in不能省略的原因


    原句In no other historical sighting did Halley's comet cause such a worldwide sensation as (Halley’s comet caused / did cause a worldwide sensation) in its return of 1910-1911.


    Halley’s comet caused such a worldwide sensation in no other historical sighting as in its return of 1910-1911.

     在GMAT中,SC最好不要创造新的句子,直接按照语义和结构分析


    这题的语义是:历史上没有哪次哈雷彗星回归造成了跟1910-1911回归的这样的世界性范围的轰动。是两个时间上的对比


     5. the "of" is used to avoid the construction "X in Y in Z".

    C选项中,为了避免有多个IN的结构,会用of来代替,这个在GMAT中是对的


    当在选项中遇到有多个一样的介词或连词时,一般正确选项要改变其中一个,避免这种结构的出现they will go out of their way to avoid "X of Y of Z", "X that Y that Z", "X to Y to Z", etc.



    16楼  | 2019-03-06 20:02:40 回复
  • 用户头像

    AUCHUI

    OG有时候是很精彩的The single subject of this sentence is Haileys
    Comet, and its single verb phrase is did cause.
    The comparison presented by the sentence is
    between adverbial phrases describing times when
    the comet was seen. Grammatically, the items
    being compared are parallel prepositional phrases
    beginning with the preposition in: in no other
    sighting and in its return in 1910-1911. This is the
    clearest, most economical way of presenting the
    information. The options that introduce a second
    verb (did or had) violate the parallelism and
    introduce a comparison between the comet itself
    (subject of the verb did cause) and the comet’s
    return (subject of the verb did or had).
    15楼  | 2018-12-14 18:07:15 回复
    • 评论用户头像
      Horacejin: 精彩在哪了? 只是默认理解为两个时间的比较。

      2019-04-17 17:24:02 回复

    •  
  • 用户头像

    xql上700

    Quote:
    (A) did its return in 1910-1911
    
    There are two ways to think about why (A) is wrong. First, we could think about what, exactly, is being compared: “in no other historical sighting did Halley’s comet cause such a worldwide sensation as ________.” The heart of the question is that we’re trying to compare what happened in other historical sightings to what happened in 1910-11. So to keep the comparison even, it makes more sense to fill in the blank above with “in its return of 1910-11.” And that’s answer choice (C). We’ll get to that one shortly.
    
    The second tool that’s helpful here: the helping verb “did” can play a variety of roles in English, but in this case, it’s basically trying to replace another verb. Think of it as analogous to a pronoun, except that it refers to a verb instead of a noun. And that means that we can replace “did” with the verb phrase that it refers back to: “cause” (or "caused", if we take some minor liberties with the verb tense). So we have: “In no other historical sighting did Halley’s comet cause such a worldwide sensation as caused its return in 1910-11.” 
    
    That’s pretty ridiculously ugly. (A) is out, whichever way you prefer to think about it.
    
    Quote:
    (B) had its 1910-1911 return
    
    I can’t make any sense of why we would use “had” here. I don’t really even understand what it means when it’s used by itself: I guess the sentence is trying to say “… as its 1910-11 return had caused”? Except that there’s no good reason to use past perfect here, and there’s no good reason to just hallucinate the word “caused” in that situation.
    
    Plus… well, the heart of the comparison needs to revolve around the phrase “in no other historical sighting”, as discussed under answer choice (A). So (B) is gone. 
    
    Quote:
    (C) in its return of 1910-1911
    
    Bingo! I know that I’m repeating what I wrote for answer choice (A), but here’s the beginning of the sentence again: “in no other historical sighting did Halley’s comet cause such a worldwide sensation as ________.” The heart of the question is that we’re trying to compare what happened in other historical sightings to what happened in 1910-11. So to keep the comparison even, it makes more sense to fill in the blank above with “in its return of 1910-11.” 
    
    And that’s exactly what (C) does. Let’s keep it.
    
    Quote:
    (D) its return of 1910-1911 did
    
    You can use the same argument for (D) as we did for (A): if “did” replaces “caused”, this makes no real sense. “In no other historical sighting did Halley’s comet cause such a worldwide sensation as its return of 1910-11 caused.” That’s not the very worst thing, but it certainly isn’t great – and it’s definitely not capturing the essence of the comparison as sharply as (C). So we can ditch (D).
    
    Quote:
    (E) its return in 1910-1911
    
    (E) isn’t completely horrible, and I’d be fine with this in real life. But again, (C) does a much, much better job of capturing the essence of the comparison. So (C) is our answer.
    14楼  | 2018-11-06 21:04:09 回复
  • 用户头像

    何杰克

    原句:Halley's Comet caused such a worldwide sensation in no other historical sighting as (it did) in its return of 1910-1911.
    13楼  | 2018-08-20 23:46:02 回复
    • 评论用户头像
      6669: 为什么 IT DID 可以省略,,求讲解

      2018-11-23 15:15:19 回复

    • 评论用户头像
      我是李大爷呀: 比较的主谓一样时就可以省

      2019-08-17 15:22:28 回复

    •  
  • 用户头像

    Rofinia

    如果补全省略内容,改为正常语序后整句话为“In no other historical sighting Halley's Comet caused such a worldwide sensation as (Halley's Comet caused) in its return of 1910-1911”括号中的主谓结构是比较结构中的第二项,由于和第一项内容基本相同,所以被省略了。
    所以本题实际上比较的是“哈雷彗星”在“other historical sighting(其他历史环境下)”和“哈雷彗星”在“它1910-1911的回归地球”的历史环境下,其造成的“轰动”的比较,“In no other historical sighting”和“in its return of 1910-1911”分别参与比较的两个主谓结构的时间状语。
    其他选项中“its return in 1910-1911”要么在和“Halley's Comet”直接比较(排除(A)、(B)、(D)),要么不知和谁在比(排除(E)),没能建立准确合理的比较关系。
    12楼  | 2018-08-10 15:42:51 回复
  • 用户头像

    冠雄

    如果改成:such a worldwide sensation as in its return of 1910–1911,那么就没有比较的逻辑关系了吧,such...as....只是一个单纯的举例啊。
    10楼  | 2018-07-31 17:50:29 回复
  • 用户头像

    ( ¨̮ )

    as后面应该是一句话是as (it did) in its return of 1910–1911,这个里面重点在于as后的主语应当是Halley's Comet ,而不是its return。遇到这种倒装题考平行,就要先把倒装顺过来Halley's Comet cause such a worldwide sensation In no other historical sighting as (),就很容易发现后面想说的是as the comet did in...而不是Its return
    9楼  | 2018-07-29 14:23:11 回复
  • 用户头像

    ( ¨̮ )

    as后面应该是一句话是as (it did) in its return of 1910–1911,这个里面重点在于as后的主语应当是Halley's Comet ,而不是its return。遇到这种倒装题考平行,就要先把倒装顺过来Halley's Comet cause such a worldwide sensation In no other historical sighting as (),就很容易发现后面想说的是as the comet did in...而不是Its return

    11楼  | 2018-07-29 14:22:56 回复
  • 用户头像

    默默

    return 回归,as有就像的意思,没有任何一次景象造成这么大彗星震动,就像回归一样,in时间的对比
    8楼  | 2018-05-08 06:27:49 回复
提交
标题图

微信公众号:LGclub

微信图

Lindy老师:2095453331

二维码
  • 手机注册
  • 邮箱注册
登录>







关闭图标

标题图

  • 图标

    知识库学习

    GMAT语法、逻辑、阅读、数学各单项备考知识点学习及测验
  • 图标

    在线做题

    包含GMAT各单项必考知识点题目、OG/PREP/GWD/雷哥讲义题目、难度650/680/700/730题库题目练习及题目解析
  • 图标

    在线模考

    语文套题/数学套题/全套仿真模考,包含GWD/PERP/精选模考等上百套套题模考
  • 图标

    在线测评

    适合5种不同基础的GMAT学员,测评后可自动出具分数报告及复习计划指导
  • 图标

    资料下载

    GMAT必备备考资料下载、鸡精下载、课程课件等免费下载
  • 图标

    课程学习

    注册会员后,可在GMAT课程区,选择免费直播课程及公开课程进行在线学习
×
请你选择你要查看的模考成绩单
立即开通 暂不开通
加载图片
网络异常